Want the bold charm of Carolina Herrera’s Good Girl without spending a fortune? In this guide, discover the best equivalent fragrances with the same sweet and seductive signature: notes of jasmine, tonka and cocoa that captivate from the first spray.
Perfect for evenings and special occasions, but affordable for all budgets.
Why is Carolina Herrera’s Good Girl so popular?
Launched in 2016, Good Girl has become a modern icon of women’s perfumery. It represents the dual nature of contemporary women: sweet and strong, elegant yet provocative.
The opening notes of almond and coffee give energy and character, while the floral heart of sambac jasmine and tuberose envelops the skin in a creamy sensuality. At the base, tonka bean, cocoa and vanilla create a warm and delicious effect that lasts for hours.
It is a fragrance that does not go unnoticed: ideal for evenings, romantic occasions or when you simply want to feel irresistible. It is no surprise that many women seek out affordable equivalents of Good Girl with the same charm and personality.
The Best Alternatives to Good Girl by Carolina Herrera
Here are three fragrances that capture the seductive essence of Good Girl, but at a more affordable price, while maintaining the same sophisticated allure.
1. Yodeyma Very Special
The most faithful: captures the sweet-floral imprint of Good Girl with jasmine, tonka, and cocoa. Sensual and enveloping, it’s the most complete and balanced dupe.
- Similarity: ●●●●○
- Longevity / sillage: ⏳⏳⏳ / high
- When to use it: evening, autumn-winter, special occasions
- For whom: loves intense and sophisticated feminine perfumes
- Pros: excellent persistence and similarity to the original
- Cons: slightly softer opening
- Average price: €25–35
Prices and availability updated on 2025-10-18 (subject to change). As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
2. iAP Pharma Nº 34
The budget option: lighter version of Good Girl with white flowers and vanilla. Ideal for daily use thanks to its sweet but discreet profile.
- Similarity: ●●●○○
- Longevity / sillage: ⏳⏳ / medium
- When to use it: day, office, spring
- For whom: looking for a simple and economical dupe
- Pros: unbeatable price and great portability
- Cons: lower persistence
- Average price: €10–15
Prices and availability updated on 2025-10-18 (subject to change). As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
3. Saphir Cool
The intense alternative: warmer and more sensual reinterpretation, with tonka, amber, and vanilla. Perfect for winter evenings and for those who love bold fragrances.
- Similarity: ●●●●○
- Longevity / sillage: ⏳⏳⏳ / high
- When to use it: evening, autumn-winter
- For whom: wants a decisive and charismatic perfume
- Pros: excellent intensity and longevity
- Cons: sweeter and denser than the original
- Average price: €18–25
Prices and availability updated on 2025-10-18 (subject to change). As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Honest opinion of the editorial staff
✅ Pros
- Yodeyma Very Special offers the highest similarity to the original Good Girl, with excellent balance between sweetness and sensuality.
- Saphir Cool wins for its intensity and longevity: an ideal choice for those who love warm and enveloping fragrances.
- iAP Pharma Nº 34 is the most accessible and light solution, perfect for daily use and for those seeking a practical perfume.
⚠️ Cons
- The more economical versions, like iAP Pharma Nº 34, have lower longevity compared to the original Carolina Herrera.
- Saphir Cool turns sweeter and more gourmand in the final phase.
- None fully replicate the complexity of the cocoa–tonka base of the original perfume.
💡 Quick takeaway: among the dupes analyzed, Yodeyma Very Special is the one that comes closest to the essence of Good Girl — elegant, sensual, and with excellent persistence. Saphir Cool is the best choice for those wanting a more intense sillage, while iAP Pharma Nº 34 represents the most economical and versatile alternative for daily use.
What is the best alternative to Carolina Herrera’s Good Girl?
Saphir Cool, iAP Pharma Nº 34 and Yodeyma Very Special are all excellent alternatives to Carolina Herrera’s Good Girl. If you prefer a fresh and sweet fragrance, Saphir Cool is the ideal choice. If you are looking for something more sophisticated and floral, iAP Pharma Nº 34 is perfect.
For those who love a sweet, woody fragrance, Yodeyma Very Special is a great choice.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
What is the most faithful dupe of Good Girl?
Among the various alternatives, Yodeyma Very Special is considered the most faithful dupe of Good Girl. It maintains the balance between floral and gourmand notes, with good longevity and a sensual sillage very similar to the original.
How long does Yodeyma Very Special last on the skin?
On average, Yodeyma Very Special lasts between 5 and 7 hours, with a noticeable sillage for most of the day. On hydrated skin or clothes, it can exceed 8 hours.
What is the most intense alternative to Good Girl?
Saphir Cool is the most intense and long-lasting version: it combines notes of tonka, amber, and vanilla for a warmer and fuller sillage, ideal for evenings or cold seasons.
Is there an economical dupe of Good Girl for daily use?
Yes, iAP Pharma Nº 34 is an excellent economical option: it has a lighter sweet-floral profile, perfect for the office or daily use. Although it has shorter longevity, it maintains the elegant essence of Good Girl.
Where to buy equivalent perfumes to Good Girl?
The most reliable dupes like Yodeyma Very Special, Saphir Cool, and iAP Pharma Nº 34 are available on Amazon and in specialized online stores for equivalent perfumes, often with great discounts and fast shipping.
Other intense feminine perfumes you might love
Alternative to Sì by Armani
Modern elegance, cassis and rose on a vanilla base. Perfect for those who love feminine but decisive trails.
Alternative to La Vie Est Belle
Sweet-gourmand with enveloping trail: a hug of praline and vanilla for special evenings.
Alternative to Olympea
Salted vanilla and bright flowers: feminine, magnetic, with an elegant and persistent trail.
Alternative to Coco Mademoiselle
Chic citrus-floral with amber base: clean, versatile, and always refined.
Conclusion: what is the best dupe for Good Girl?
If you are looking for the strongest resemblance with a seductive trail and good persistence, the recommended choice is Yodeyma Very Special. For a more intense and nocturnal trail, consider Saphir Cool.
If, on the other hand, you want an economical, everyday option, iAP Pharma Nº 34 offers a light, sweet floral profile that is easy to wear.
